Kirchoff's Law Proven False

Go down

Kirchoff's Law Proven False Empty Kirchoff's Law Proven False

Post by LloydK on Sat Aug 19, 2017 9:24 am

Looks like Miles' friend Stephen Crothers is on the CNPS Forum. He says in the email string:

Re: Q&A with Sabine Hossenfelder: Consultant for Armchair Physicists
Friday, August 18, 2017 9:26 PM
"Stephen Crothers" <>

Here is a simple experiment proving Kirchhoff's Law of Thermal Emission false. This puts big bang cosmology and all its paraphernalia to the sword.

Professor Pierre-Marie Robitaille,
Is Kirchhoff's Law True? The Experiment!

Steve Crothers

Maybe I'll ask him to explain how this finding destroys Big Bang etc.


Posts : 448
Join date : 2014-08-10

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Kirchoff's Law Proven False Empty Re: Kirchoff's Law Proven False

Post by Cr6 on Sat Dec 29, 2018 11:33 pm

Here are a few posts from

Dr. Pierre-Marie Robitaille: Sun on Trial | EU2014

For nearly 150 years despite the lack of observational evidence, the Sun has been considered to be a ball of gaseous material. Such a postulate rests on mathematical arguments. Nonetheless, observations, not mathematics, properly determine the phases of matter. In this light, a systematic review of 40 solar findings provides ample proof that the Sun is comprised of condensed matter In this presentation, the phase of the Sun will be discussed by contrasting the gas-based Standard Solar Model (SSM) with the Liquid Metallic Hydrogen Solar Model (LMHSM). Unlike the SSM, the LMHSM does not permit the Sun to radiate internally. This is the third of three talks that Dr. Robitaille presented at EU2014.

Pierre-Marie Robitaille, PhD is a Professor of Radiology at The Ohio State University, with a joint appointment in Chemical Physics. He initially trained as a spectroscopist and has wide ranging knowledge of instrumentation in the radio and microwave bands. A recognized expert in image acquisition and analysis, Professor Robitaille was responsible for doubling the world record in Magnetic Resonance Imaging in 1998. In 2000, he turned his attention to thermodynamics and astrophysics, demonstrating that the universality advanced in Kirchhoff’s Law of Thermal Emission is invalid. He has published extensively on the microwave background, highlighting that this signal arises from water on the Earth and has no relationship to cosmology and has recently published a paper on the Liquid Metallic Hydrogen Solar Model (LMHSM).

Dr. Pierre-Marie Robitaille: On the Validity of Kirchhoff’s Law | EU2014

THIS ONE WILL BE OF GREATEST INTEREST TO THEORETICAL PHYSICISTS. Please help out by directing the attention of physicists to this video.

Kirchhoff’s law of thermal emission (formulated in 1860) is presented and demonstrated to be invalid. This law is crucial to our understanding of radiation within arbitrary cavities. Kirchhoff’s law rests at the heart of condensed matter physics and astrophysics. Its collapse can be directly associated with 1) the loss of universality in Planck’s law (Planck’s constant and Boltzmann’s constant are no longer universal in nature), 2) the collapse of the gaseous Sun as described in Standard Solar Models, and 3) the inability of the Big Bang to act as the source of the microwave background.
The Liquid Metallic Hydrogen Model of the Sun and the Solar Atmosphere V.
On the Nature of the Corona

Pierre-Marie Robitaille
Department of Radiology, The Ohio State University, 395 W. 12th Ave, Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA.
The E-corona is the site of numerous emission lines associated with high ionization
states (i.e. FeXIV-FeXXV).Modern gaseous models of the Sun require that these states
are produced by atomic irradiation, requiring the sequential removal of electrons to infinity,
without an associated electron acceptor. This can lead to computed temperatures
in the corona which are unrealistic (i.e. 30–100 MK contrasted to solar core values
of 16 MK). In order to understand the emission lines of the E-corona, it is vital to
recognize that they are superimposed upon the K-corona, which produces a continuous
spectrum, devoid of Fraunhofer lines, arising from this same region of the Sun. It has
been advanced that the K-corona harbors self-luminous condensed matter (Robitaille
P.M. The Liquid Metallic Hydrogen Model of the Sun and the Solar Atmosphere II.
Continuous Emission and Condensed Matter Within the Corona. Progr. Phys., 2013,
v. 3, L8–L10; Robitaille P.M. The Liquid Metallic Hydrogen Model of the Sun and the
Solar Atmosphere III. Importance of Continuous Emission Spectra from Flares, Coronal
Mass Ejections, Prominences, and Other Coronal Structures. Progr. Phys., 2013,
v. 3, L11–L14). Condensed matter can possess elevated electron affinities which may
strip nearby atoms of their electrons. Such a scenario accounts for the high ionization
states observed in the corona: condensed matter acts to harness electrons, ensuring the
electrical neutrality of the Sun, despite the flow of electrons and ions in the solar winds.
Elevated ionization states reflect the presence of materials with high electron affinities
in the corona, which is likely to be a form of metallic hydrogen, and does not translate
into elevated temperatures in this region of the solar atmosphere. As a result, the many
mechanisms advanced to account for coronal heating in the gaseous models of the Sun
are superfluous, given that electron affinity, not temperature, governs the resulting spectra.
In this regard, the presence of highly ionized species in the corona constitutes the
thirty-first line of evidence that the Sun is composed of condensed matter.


Posts : 1151
Join date : 2014-08-09

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Back to top

Permissions in this forum:
You can reply to topics in this forum