How's this Video for explaining Electric Currents?
2 posters
Page 1 of 1
How's this Video for explaining Electric Currents?
The title is How Electricity Actually Works
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oI_X2cMHNe0
It credits the electric field rather than electrons as the source of electrical energy. It says positive charges line up on one side of the circuit and electrons on the other side. Does that seem to be correct?
It doesn't say that photons are the electric field, but the explanation sounds to me like it's close to correct. Yes? No?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oI_X2cMHNe0
It credits the electric field rather than electrons as the source of electrical energy. It says positive charges line up on one side of the circuit and electrons on the other side. Does that seem to be correct?
It doesn't say that photons are the electric field, but the explanation sounds to me like it's close to correct. Yes? No?
Lloyd- Posts : 191
Join date : 2022-04-12
Chromium6 likes this post
Re: How's this Video for explaining Electric Currents?
.
Lloyd, The youtube video you cited is a follow-up to Derek Muller’s previous Veritasium video, The Big Misconception About Electricity. 14,189,710 views Nov 19, 2021. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bHIhgxav9LY
In that video’s reference section Derek cites:
Sefton, I. M. (2002). Understanding electricity and circuits: What the text books don’t tell you. In Science Teachers’ Workshop -- https://ve42.co/Sefton
Miles has written the paper, How a Battery Circuit Works * using Sefton’s paper as a starting point. In his intro paragraph, Miles wrote.
Airman. So Miles chose Sefton’s paper because its a relatively good start, but not a complete mechanical description.
*
126. How a Battery Circuit Works.
http://milesmathis.com/seft.pdf
Not the mathematical or field model, but the full mechanical model, with photons. 9pp.
.
Lloyd, The youtube video you cited is a follow-up to Derek Muller’s previous Veritasium video, The Big Misconception About Electricity. 14,189,710 views Nov 19, 2021. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bHIhgxav9LY
In that video’s reference section Derek cites:
Sefton, I. M. (2002). Understanding electricity and circuits: What the text books don’t tell you. In Science Teachers’ Workshop -- https://ve42.co/Sefton
Miles has written the paper, How a Battery Circuit Works * using Sefton’s paper as a starting point. In his intro paragraph, Miles wrote.
A reader sent me a link to an article from 2002 by Ian Sefton of University of Sydney, who tries to explain how a circuit works. This article is part of a Science Teacher's Workshop, and I must imagine that it is quite helpful in some ways, since it clears up a few longstanding and wide-ranging misunderstandings. However, Sefton's explanation of the circuit is still not mechanical, as I think he would admit. In this paper, I will clarify the circuit even further, by showing that it is the motion of photons, not electrons, that creates it. As we proceed, remember that all I say applies only to the battery circuit. We have lots of electric circuits, and it turns out we have to analyze each one separately. Some things will be the same, some things will be different.
Airman. So Miles chose Sefton’s paper because its a relatively good start, but not a complete mechanical description.
Airman. I’d say Derek credits both the electric field within the wire, as well as the charge distribution on the wire’s surface. Derek also admits that after the switch is closed the "magnetic field" expands and extends beyond the wires resulting in an instantaneous circuit current. The wires behave like a transmission line. I get the strong impression Derek read Miles' paper as well as Sefton's.Lloyd wrote. It credits the electric field rather than electrons as the source of electrical energy. It says positive charges line up on one side of the circuit and electrons on the other side. Does that seem to be correct?
Airman. I’d agree, Derek’s explanation is closer to correct compared to most mainstream explanations. Of course, as Miles explains - in depth, the circuit isn’t being driven by an electric field, but by the charge field.Lloyd wrote. It doesn't say that photons are the electric field, but the explanation sounds to me like it's close to correct. Yes? No?
*
126. How a Battery Circuit Works.
http://milesmathis.com/seft.pdf
Not the mathematical or field model, but the full mechanical model, with photons. 9pp.
.
LongtimeAirman- Admin
- Posts : 2070
Join date : 2014-08-10
Chromium6 likes this post
Re: How's this Video for explaining Electric Currents?
Thanks for the comments, Airman. Maybe I'll get time to discuss this in some detail before long. I just quit my full-time job yesterday, so I should have more time for such things, but the ruling class is keeping everyone busy trying to adapt to the constant increasingly severe societal changes they're throwing at us. I hear that the U.S. is now selling a lot of our petroleum to Europe due to it being no longer available from Russia. So we're going to have extreme shortages here soon, jacking the prices up to $10 a gallon for gas & diesel.
Lloyd- Posts : 191
Join date : 2022-04-12
Re: How's this Video for explaining Electric Currents?
.
I'd be happy to discuss the circuit when you find the time. I agree, the world’s current environmental, societal and political changes can be overwhelming. It would be a relief if science were to show any positive changes. I happen to believe the more people realize major changes are upon us the better. Remember retirement isn’t for the weak, stay positive and keep adapting. Good luck with your post career life.
.
I'd be happy to discuss the circuit when you find the time. I agree, the world’s current environmental, societal and political changes can be overwhelming. It would be a relief if science were to show any positive changes. I happen to believe the more people realize major changes are upon us the better. Remember retirement isn’t for the weak, stay positive and keep adapting. Good luck with your post career life.
.
LongtimeAirman- Admin
- Posts : 2070
Join date : 2014-08-10
Similar topics
» Explaining the P-N Junction without Holes
» Birkeland Currents
» A certain telluric currents?
» The Ambient Field Currents
» Microcosm - Physics
» Birkeland Currents
» A certain telluric currents?
» The Ambient Field Currents
» Microcosm - Physics
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum